The WFB Admins’ Top 15 “Supernatural” Episodes List: #10
Ardeospina’s #10:
“Dark Side of the Moon”
Why: This episode is such an emotional roller coaster, and every time you think it can’t get more emotional, BAM! It does. I think this is Dabb and Loflin’s best episode as a writing team. They certainly pulled out all the stops.
The opening to this episode, with Roy and Walt and them blowing the Winchesters away, was so intense, and it only got better from there. The version of heaven presented in this episode is unique and horrifying all at the same time. It’s like the “Matrix,” and almost everybody took the blue pill. The way heaven uses Sam’s memories to manipulate Dean into losing faith in his brother is so devious and just like the angels. They’re willing to use all the tricks in the book to make Dean say yes, even a low blow like showing him all the times Sam was happy without him and none of the times Sam was happy WITH Dean and his family. Because you know there were plenty of good times that Sam would gladly have shown Dean.
Speaking of slimy angels, how horrid was Zachariah in this episode? Using Mary like that was just way over the line. Kurt Fuller really nailed the sleazy, smarmy nature of Zachariah perfectly, didn’t he? How amazing was Joshua by contrast? I love, love, loved Joshua, and I really wish we could have seen more of him. Maybe he’ll show up again. I also love the way they shot that scene in the garden. The angles and the lighting with Joshua were beautiful.
This episode also gave us Ash back! ASH! Of course he runs a Roadhouse in heaven, helping Sam and Dean when they die, hopping through other heavens, hanging out with Pamela. You know he’s found Jo and Ellen by now, too, and maybe Bill. Aw, isn’t that a nice thought, the Harvelles all together again?
So now I’m going to ruin that happy feeling by reminding you that this episode has quite possibly the saddest ending to any episode on the show. Sam and Dean come back to life, they tell Castiel that God isn’t interested, and we have to watch as Castiel loses his faith in his father. Ouch. Then he gives Dean back his amulet, saying “it’s worthless.” And then we have to watch as DEAN THROWS IT IN THE TRASH!!!! Damn, please remove this knife from my heart. Though, I have to say, I’m kind of glad they haven’t tried to bring the amulet back. I think maybe Sam fished it out of the trash, because hey, it was supposed to find God, so maybe it will be useful. But it doesn’t mean the same thing to Dean that it used to, so tryiing to force it to again doesn’t make sense. It served its purpose. Now it’s time to let the amulet enjoy its retirement.
Favorite quote: I can’t pick between two, so I’m just not going to.
Walt: Shoot him!
Dean: Go ahead, Roy. Do it. But I’m gonna warn you: when I come back, I’ma be pissed.
I love that Dean said “when.” That must have been terrifying for those two. Not if, WHEN. I’m still waiting for the “Dean hunts them down and is pissed” episode.
Zachariah: In heaven, I have six wings and four faces, one of which is a lion.
This is just quintessential Zachariah, bragging about his wings and lion face. And he’s soooo smarmy when he says it. I just like it.
Favorite Scene: as much as I adore the scene with Joshua in the garden, I have to go with the obvious choice of Dean’s memory of shooting off fireworks. It’s just such a beautiful scene. Sam is so damn happy, Dean is so damn happy to relive it. Sam dancing around in firework sparks while Bob Dylan plays in the background… It’s timeless. One of the most beautiful things the show has done, in my opinion.
There you have it! We’ve cracked the top 10! What do you think about our choices? Are any of these episodes on your top 15 list? The choices keeo getting harder and harder! Stay tuned tomorrow for #9!
Oh, Alice…we’re kindred spirits. On the Head of A Pin is one of my all time favorites along with Point of No Return. To me both of these episodes speak to me so much (actually volumes) about the brothers relationship. I love to go back and play them all the time!
Could someone please help me to understand why at the end of “On the Head of a Pin” Castiel refuses to heal Dean? I think his exact words are something like: “I can’t” – not “I won’t”, but “I can’t”. I have never been able to understand [i]why[/i]. Cas has the ability to heal Dean but he chooses not to? Can someone explain this to me? Thank you!
I think it’s because at that time, Cas was still the good soldier and taking his orders from heaven although I believe he was starting to question them. I think upper management (Zachariah) said not to heal Dean and Cas did what he was told even though you could tell he was conflicted by the orders.
[i]”Cas was still the good soldier and taking his orders from heaven”[/i]
OK, so Cas & Uriel are under orders to get Dean to torture Alistair and find out who is murdering angels. While doing what heaven has asked, Dean gets beaten to a pulp – Dean is Michael’s vessel – but Zachariah gives orders [i]NOT[/i] to heal Dean?
Does this actually make sense? I am still confused! What would motivate Zach (or any angel) not to heal Michael’s vessel while he is injured doing what they demanded of him?
I appreciate your help rmoats8621. Thanks for trying but I guess I am too dense to get this!
I think Zachariah healed Dean himself, since the next episode is “It’s a terrible life”, where the boys get their minds scrubed. Another angel manipulation.
Maybe it has something to do with the nature of the demon that tortured Dean. Because Alastair was so powerful, even the angels could not heal someone affected by this? I’ve always questioned that also Suzee, it was never really properly addressed. Just one of those things that we’ll never get an answer to. But what a great episode. One of my favourites for sure.
In my mind, Zachariah always ordered Cas not to heal Dean, because he wanted Dean to feel weak.
[i]”because he wanted Dean to feel weak.”[/i]
Thanks, Fluffy! Now [i]that’s[/i] an idea I never had that really clicks with me! It is consistent with all of Zach’s actions and motivation. He would try ANYTHING to force Dean in line.
Gee, now I am wondering (like in Dark Side of the Moon) if Zach wasn’t behind loosening the water line bolts instead of Uriel? Perhaps Zach orchestrated this whole scene to work toward his own purpose??? Now[i][b] that[/b][/i] would really make the most sense, no?
I´m pretty sure, that was Uriel, but you need to remember, at that point, the goals of Uriel and Zachariah aligned perfectly.
The Angels WANTED Sam to release Lucifer.
They always subtly pushed him in that direction.
Without Lucifer, no big endfight.
And that was both demons and angels wanted.
Only after Dean had been pushed too far and close to breaking point by Alistair, had Uriels purpose been served.
I´m pretty sure, Zachariah knew, who was killing the Angels and silently manipulating him too.
The Angels WANTED Dean to go to Hell.
They didn´t rescue him, before he broke the first seal, because that was exactly the goal.
And if it had taken a thousand years, they wouldn´t have saved him before it happened.
Just the same, as Alistair saying, that John had been so much stronger than Dean had been a lie.
It never was John who was supposed to break the first seal.
It always had to be Dean, because of Sam and the fact, they were brothers.
Hi Suzee, Yeah, I always thought that ‘Dark Side’ was a complete Zachariah mind &@%! if you know what I mean. By the time ‘Dark Side’ aired Dean had been subjected to three total manipulations orchestrated by Zach 1) It’s a Terrible Life, 2) The End 3) Dark Side of the Moon. I was actually disappointed that Dean didn’t seem to recognize that he was being played; he had the other two times Zach tried to manipulate him… so why not this time?
Quoting Fluffy:
[quote]In my mind, Zachariah always ordered Cas not to heal Dean, because he wanted Dean to feel weak.[/quote]You know, that actually makes sense to me. I’m going with your theory, thanks. 🙂
These lists are making me want to rewatch, not that I need that much of an excuse to watch SPN, but I just don’t have the time right now!
sweetondean-I freaking love the teddy bear, definitely something only SPN can pull off. My family thought I was nuts though, because I thought it was just so damn entertaining. I was like “oh look-a seven foot, depressed, drunk, porn-loving teddy bear!” *blank looks and crickets chirping*
Alice-On The Head of a Pin was a masterpiece. I remember being a wreck the first time I watched it. I don’t rewatch that often though because it is that intense, so I need to work myself up for it.
Ardeospina-Definitely one of my all-time favourites. I had to pick my jaw up from the floor when Roy and Walt killed Sam and Dean (I still jump, too). I think even[i] I [/i] cringed back into my seat a little when Dean said “When I come back.” Then I got a little teary eyed at the firworks scene, while at the same time cheering the guest-star list: Chad Lindberg! Traci Dinwiddie! Colin Ford! Samantha Smith! And yeah, the amulet scene broke my heart into little pieces. I still think Sam got it back, though.
May I just mention… I hate Zachariah.
I don´t really hate Alistair or Azazel, but Zachariah must be the worst SOB on earth, heaven and hell.
No demon, no monster has done as much damage to the emotional and mental health of the boys, which in my world includes Adam, as this angel.
Which is only made worse, because he´s a freaking angel!
And if you can´t trust those, who are the warriors of good anymore… who can you trust?
Anyways… love your joices! Though I would put On the Head of a Pin alot higher on the list.
That episode just blew me away!
Jensen Ackles was so perfect and Christopher Heyerdahl (aside from being Thor Heyerdahls nephew and causing all sorts of fangirlish squees in me!) was SOOOOOOOOOOO absolutely, beautifully, breathtakingly evil and plain awesome.
Not to talk about the way you could see and feel the doubt creeping into Castiels mind.
Sam´s rage, when Dean was in danger was a thing of beauty too. You rarely see him all protective and possessive, but I love it, when it shows.
And Anna… I loved Anna ^^
I loved the whole episode. Period. It will always be in my Top 5
Ardeospina, I love “Dark Side of the Moon”! When Dean first wakes up in Heaven and he’s driving down the road, it was such a beautiful shot, I’m hoping Heaven is actually like that. Only with Pink Floyd playing in the backgroud. 😆 [quote]I love that Dean said “when.” That must have been terrifying for those two. Not if, WHEN. I’m still waiting for the “Dean hunts them down and is pissed” episode.[/quote]This right here is why I love Dean Winchester so much. He says pretty much the same thing to Samuel in “Caged Heat” when he’s locked in that room, “I’m going to make it out of here, and when I do, I’m going to kill you” (or something to that effect). I would never want to be on the other side of one of those stares! 😮
[i]”The opening to this episode, with Roy and Walt and them blowing the Winchesters away, was so intense”[/i]
Ardeo: You can’t forget to mention how incredible Dean’s final exchange with Roy was right before Walt blew Dean away! I mean, there are TWO men with shotguns trained on Dean Winchester and they had just murdered his brother. It is so friggin’ great that Dean is SO intimidating (using only words) that Roy physically backs away from Dean and can’t pull the trigger! [b]Jensen is SO badass[/b] in that scene!
Still waiting for Dean to meet up with Roy and Walt. 🙂
My fav if the three is On the Head of a Pin. The emotional range of the actors is unbelievable. Again Jensen says so much without actually speaking. The anguish on Deans face when he tells Cas you can’t ask me to do this…you won’t like what walks back thru that door. When the torture starts, Deans tells Alistair no matter how much torture he endured in hell he could still dream and this is what Dean would dream of. The look of terror on Alistairs face was perfect.
How heartbroken is Dean when he finds out he broke the fist seal. When Dean tears up I tear up, the emotion he evokes during that scene without saying a word. You can see his thoughts as Alistair tells him what he has done. ” We owe it all to you Dean Winchester”
I knew Ruby was evil and Gen’s portrayal of Ruby is my favorite. The demon blood totally surprised me. I figured Sam and Ruby were having sex and she was teaching him some major black magic demon mojo. But I never saw the demon blood as his source of power till that episode. Again more was said in the Sam/Ruby scene without words.
It s not often we ever get to see Sam be the protector but this episode finally showed him stepping in to the role. His look of despair while sitting by Deans bedside looking at the monitors again heart wrenching. His tearful demand of Cas ” miracle now” and lambasting Cas for Deans injuries.
Final scene Cas ” You alright”, explains to Dean his true roll in stopping Lucifer.
Dean’s speech to Cas…telling Cas he should have left him in hell. Tears streaming, self loathing. ” I’ m not the man either of our dad’s wanted me to be, find someone else it’s not me ” more tears, omg kills me every time.
This one is in my top five!
Yeah, these are all on my top 15 list for sure. All excellent choices and impeccable episodes!
Just disagree a little about the amulet. That little thing still missing is a big part of what’s missing in the show. The brotherly love and devotion and TRUST that, if it is coming back, is crawling like a sick snail! I want it back meaning exactly what it did before! That scene with the fireworks just fills my heart with joy for the both of them, and the end just destroys that entirely. 😥 I would never suffer this much for any other show except for these brothers which I love dearly.
Wish they could revisit Heaven, before they go there permanently that is, and meet up with Ash, Ellen, Jo, Andy,mom and dad, Adam, Rufus and of course Bobby.
And “On the Head of a Pin” is just perfection and gut-wrenching in every way. The acting — what can I say? Perfection from all. Ben Edlund is definitely a genius!
I just need to say that most of these picks are in my top five! Haha! Yes, my top five is huge. 😛
Yes! These three episodes are amazing, right?! The scene at the end of “On the Head of a Pin” in which Dean tells Cas to find someone else is one of my favorite scenes of the series, and the reveal that Dean broke the first seal floored me. It’s a wonder that this one did not make my own top 15! I suppose that overall the episode is flawless for what it is and is perfect within the context of the season, but on its own is a bit slow and heavy with mythology compared with the episodes I ranked higher. Still, everything you’ve said about it is true, and that makes me want to reconsider!
My #10 episode is “Lazarus Rising”, for pretty much all of the reasons Ardeospina gave in her #11 write up. The only thing I would add is that I thought it was one of the most suspensful episodes working up to the introduction of Castiel. Though it crossed my mind that it might be and angel after Pamela was blinded, I must admit I still didn’t believe they would go there. But they did, and they owned it.
“You are NOT invited!” – Dean, to “Grumpy”