Recap: “Bad Day At Black Rock”
I’ll make my point here that I never liked Bela and it’s her that prevents this from being a “perfect” episode for me. I’ll stop there though because Sam’s bad luck makes for joyous madcap insanity! Bela leaves the restaurant with the rabbit’s foot in her towel (meaning she hasn’t touched it), a smug smile and throws away the black wig. For some reason though, the change in hair color as we find out later in the season doesn’t stop Sam’s lusting. Sam and Dean run after her and Sam takes a hilarious pratfall onto the asphalt behind Dean. “Wow, you suck,” says Dean. A little sympathy here? The boy’s hurt. Ouch! Two perfectly skinned and bloody knees with holes ripped in the jeans. “So what now your luck turns bad?” Dean asks helping Sam up. Yeah, that sounds right. “Wonder how bad?” Okay, you asked…
Back to Kubrick and Creedy checking the Biggersons menu on the website. See, they do have a deep fried onion! Guess who’s picture they see? Kubrick only grins upward, taking this to be his sign from God. Considering we have a good idea who God is, he’s pretty right! God is writing these pages right now.
Back to Grossman who’s toasting Wayne’s memory to a terrible photoshopped yet cheesy in a funny way photo of them in sombreros drinking either in Mexico or a Mexican restaurant. I think latter. He pours tequila on the floor while playing “Via Con Dios” in the background. This must be how they mourn buddies in Connecticut. Sam and Dean walk in unannounced and Grossman isn’t too happy to see them. Dean tells him he knows what happened and how its bad luck. Grossman tells him to “piss off.” Does anyone say that anymore? I’ve said it before many times, they should just bleep the cuss words.
Dean goes back to the interrogation, asking for “her” name. Sam gets up and he ain’t looking so good. The hair is a mess anyway. Grossman won’t give so Dean lets him know it wasn’t a freak accident before breaking out the “I can read people” ploy. The sour luck killed his friend, is going to kill Sam and who knows who else. He knows Grossman isn’t a killer. Yeah, except he did actually try to choke Sam to death earlier. It must be the grief though for Dean gets through.
Kubrick is standing outside the RV and we get full view of the bible thumping bumper stickers. “How would Jesus drive?” “Don’t make me come down there. – God” “Bethlehem or bust.” Hmm, there’s Ben Edlund playing with his Jesus again! Creedy has something chicken shaped wrapped in foil in his arms and I really don’t want to know. I’m sure that’s funny in some parts of the country. He tells Kubrick no one knows where Sam and Dean went and they didn’t pay for the meal so there’s no credit card receipt. Kubrick isn’t worried, they’ll turn up. “Because there’s a higher power at work here, I know it now.” That is also true! Okay its hoodoo and not Jesus, but he’s half right.
Here we go, one of the most referenced, iconic scenes in the series! Sam and Dean walk out of the apartment building and Dean gets a call. It’s Bobby. Dean avoids the huge wad of chewed gum on the asphalt but guess who isn’t so lucky? Sam hears the squish and gets the droopy shoulders and pout of disgust.
In the meantime Bobby tells Dean he found a cleansing ritual that will do the trick. Dean is pleased to hear this but tells Bobby Sam lost the foot. That’s obvious since Sam is struggling in the background trying to get the gum off his shoe. Dean with his back turned carries on the conversation with Bobby just so we get the full effect of Sam struggling in the background. He tells Bobby a hot chick stole it from him but can’t remember the name. Sam, who has found a broken sewer grate by now to scrape off the gum, tells him Legosi. Bobby knows that name, Bela.
As we all saw coming, Sam makes one more hard push on the sewer grate and his shoe falls off. Judging by the “plop” sound, it fell far down. While Sam hopelessly looks for the shoe Dean learns the culprit is Bela Talbot, not a hunter but she knows her way around. She’s been out of the country but Bobby might know how to find her. Dean thanks him but is given one final warning. “Just look out for your brother you idgit.”
Now back to Sam, who has given up his search and is standing there with shoulders slumped looking very forlorn. “What?” Dean asks. Wait for it…”I lost my shoe,” Sam says with a huge pout. We see the shoeless foot and one hilarious frown on his face. Dean just rolls his eyes. Bwah!!!! No wonder Jared is constantly asked to say that line at cons. It’s priceless! The poor puppy has been kicked.
Dean takes Sam into the motel room and whoa, this place is outrageous! I think season three was the best for motel rooms. Sam is whining now, wondering what it is he’s supposed to do. Nothing of course. “I don’t want you doing anything. Just sit right here and don’t move, okay? Don’t turn on the light, don’t turn off the light. Don’t even scratch your nose.”
Dean leaves the pouting Sam quickly behind, who’s making weird facial expressions because now his nose itches. So Sam scratches his nose! This most outrageous room is shown in a wide shot, which just adds to the absurdity ten fold. The loud floral wallpaper, the room divider made of circles and the giant red circle behind Sam? Oh that’s rich.
Okay, now we’re in Queens and I’m going to skip ahead a bit because I don’t like Bela. She is on the phone bitching about some deal and sees Dean on the security camera. She handles the rabbit’s foot with tongs and goes for her gun. By the front door that alarm going off and a sticky note that says “Turn Around.” She does and there’s Dean pointing a gun at her. “You left without your tip.” Bela draws her gun, so I guess this is a draw.

Alice Jester is the founder, editor-in-chief, head writer, programmer, web designer, site administrator, marketer, and moderator for The Winchester Family Business. She is a 30 year IT applications and database expert with a penchant for creative and freelance writing in her spare (ha!!) time. That’s on top of being a wife, mother of two active kids, and four loving (aka needy) pets.
As usual, great recap Alice! I now must re-watch this episode for the millionth time. The photos were priceless – the shoe scene had me in hysterics again too. My favourite is the last picture because you can clearly see Jared fighting the laughter – great moment to capture!
Hindsight aside, I could have tolerated Bela and didn’t mind her in the episode up until she shot Sam and then managed to snake the lottery tickets (even if it did give that great “son-of-a-bitch!” moment). I wouldn’t have minded her in a few episodes trying to outsmart them, with a few witty exchanges back and forth. The thing that killed me about Bela was that she ALWAYS beat them (except that last time) and while Sam and Dean are many things, easy marks they aren’t! (rant over)
Thanks Alice, this was a fun read!
I totally understand your soft spot for season 3, Alice – it gave us many great episodes like the one you took on here. Thanks for this fun read – I’m going to watch it now. I haven’t done so in a while.
This episode has some of the best faces on our heroes, bitch face here, surprise face here, I-lost-my-shoe face here, I’m-Batman face there…. I love, love, love it. And the dialogue is some of the best ever. And those little hints (like the stickers on Kubrick’s bus – ‘DOn’t make me come down there – GOd’ ‘How Would Jesus Drive?’, brilliant exposing of the religious fanatic)…
I know you can’t abide Bella, but I learned to appreciate her role in the show and the kind of woman she became. But you know that ;-)…
Thanks again, Alice, for this fabulous recap! :D, Jas
I loved this recap Alice. This episode was so full of great comedic moments. And the two Js were both excellent at the slapstick comedy.
I too came to the show in season 3, so never could understand why so many disliked it. I became a fan after watching Supernatural Christmas, bought the dvds and completely fell for Dean and Sam and haven’t recovered since.
I never hated the actress who played Bela. I thought she did a great job being completely annoying. Hated Bela always one-upping our boys though and shooting Sam was inexcusable. So sorry poor Dean lost his windfall. That would have saved a lot of his time hustling for motel and food money. 🙁
i love this episode it’s one of my favourites … love the recap! especially the photo’s.
for the record i actually liked Bella in this episode and if she had stayed a one episode character i would have continued to like her, in the end she just ended up irratating me which i think was probabyl more the fault of the writers than the actress. on a really pedantic note her accent really annoyed me, no one english actually sounds like that … seriously!
anyway minor rant over with! again loved the recap! x
Lovely recap Alice. This is one of my favorite episodes! Season three title card is my favorite too and I never did like Bela. So nice to reminisce with a wonderful episode like this. Can only hope s6 will provide a few like this too.
Sometimes I think I’m the only one that likes Bela. She had a certain appeal and I like a bit of banter and bickering between a man and a woman. I just wish they had given her back story earlier. If only it had been a full season.
But good recap. Love this episode.
Great recap of a great episode. Season three shouldn’t be shortchanged merely because it’s, er, shorter, look at the evidence: this episode, arguably the finest comedy piece they’ve ever done (Mystery Spot isn’t 100% sidesplitting, that last half is an emotional mofo), Casey, Dean as pop, Casey, the bloody death of a supreme villain, Casey, Xmas Is Dead, Casey, Mystery Spot, Casey, a supreme homage to John Carpenter, Casey, a ridiculously fantastic finale.
Alas, poor Kubrick, Jesus knew him well.
Hi Alice
Once again loved the recap.
This is one my favourite episodes, definitely in the top 10.
I have to admit I didn’t even mind Bela. (runs for cover):o
I wanted to punch her out when she shot Sam of course, but I still enjoyed the banter between her and Dean.
Randal…I’m sensing you may have had a thing for Casey??? 😎
Loved the recap Alice, great depiction of the scenes and I love your comments. Can’t help but smile, laugh and cringe right along with you. And Randal, obsessed with Casey much? Too funny! She is one of the few demons on the show I kinda liked, although for different reasons I think than yours. 😆
Very fun recap, Alice. I’m glad that you’re going back and updating some of your recaps because I really like to read them. And they usually make me want to re-watch the episode! This one did for sure. It helps when the episode is this great, though.