WFBBabyBanner

Follow Us

Text Size

EW Ultimate Guide to Supernatural

Family Don't End With Blood

Featuring a chapter from Nightsky!

Share This

It’s that time of year again!  Time when we take a look at the season gone by and through a series of articles scrutinize the hell out of it.  Or, perhaps we just have some fun.  This article definitely falls on the fun side.  It’s time to play, Rank ‘Em in Five (or Ten) Minutes!
The rules are simple.  Below is the list of all 23 “Supernatural” Season Twelve episodes.  Based on your personal opinion, rank all of them from best to worst.  The key is though you’ve got to do it in five to ten minutes.  The idea here is to get your gut reaction.  Once they are ranked you are done.  No extra evaluation or second guessing.  Share your results in the comments.  
 
Yes, some of you probably noticed I changed the title this year.   Season Twelve has thrown me for a loop.  There were so many “middle of the road” episodes and pure filler that once I got past the best and the worst, figuring out the middle was a bit tough.  I didn’t even remember a lot of of these episodes or what happened.  I had to use our handy/dandy Supernatural Season Twelve Episode Guide to jog the memory.  It’s my recommendation to review the guide before getting started.  
 
This game is always fun because it’s interesting to see which episodes end up having a common ranking and which ones are all over the map.  It just goes to show, everyone sees an episode differently.  
 
Here are the 23 episodes in order of airing: 
 
Keep Calm and Carry On
Mamma Mia
The Foundry
American Nightmare
The One You’ve Been Waiting For
Celebrating the Life of Asa Fox
Rock Never Dies
LOTUS
First Blood
Lily Sunder Has Some Regrets
Regarding Dean
Stuck in the Middle With You
Family Feud
The Raid
Somewhere Between Heaven and Hell
Ladies Drink Free
The British Invasion
The Memory Remains
The Future
Twigs, Twine and Tasha Banes
There’s Something About Mary
Who We Are
All Along The Watchtower
 
As a demonstration, here is my ranking of episodes from best to worst.  For the record, this ranking took me 8 minutes to do.  An all time worst for me.  
 
Who We Are
Stuck in the Middle With You
Regarding Dean
The Raid
LOTUS
The Memory Remains
Celebrating the Life of Asa Fox
The Future
Lily Sunder Has Some Regrets
Mamma Mia
Twigs, Twine and Tasha Banes
American Nightmare
The Foundry
Keep Calm and Carry On
All Along The Watchtower
Somewhere Between Heaven and Hell
Rock Never Dies
Ladies Drink Free
Family Feud
First Blood
The One You’ve Been Waiting For
The British Invasion
There’s Something About Mary
 
Okay, it’s your turn!  Rank ‘Em in Five (or Ten) Minutes!