Our “Go To” Supernatural Episodes from all 15 Seasons

In honor of “Supernatural” season 15 and the entire series being released on DVD on Tuesday, May 25th, I asked the WFB staff members if they would partake in a little exercise I like to do every now and then.  I call it the “Supernatural” ‘go to’ episodes list.  What if you only have 1 hour and there’s a “Supernatural” season DVD set in front of you.  What episode would you choose to watch?  It usually isn’t the best, or the most important to the story, or most critically acclaimed episode.  It’s that one favorite that sends you to your happy place, as if it was made just for you.  

What’s fun about this exercise is no matter how much you do it, your choices tend to change over time.  I’ve done several of these lists through the years yet they always tend to shift a little.  This time is no different.  What’s really fun though is that this is the first time we’ve done this for all 15 seasons!  Sure, picking just one is tougher for some seasons than others, but overall there has to be at least one gem each season.  The question is, are those gems the same for all of us?  Let’s check out the lists below for the answer.  
 

Nightsky

Season One:  1.09 “Home” 
Season Two:  2.17 “Heart” 
Season Three: 3.12 “Jus in Bello” 
Season Four:  4.09 “I Know What You Did Last Summer”
Season Five:  5.22 “Swan Song”
Season Six: 6.15 “The French Mistake”
Season Seven: 7.12 “Time after Time”
Season Eight: 8.23 “Sacrifice”
Season Nine: 9.11 “First Born”
Season Ten: 10.05 “Fan Fiction”
Season Eleven: 11.20 “Don’t Call Me Shurley”
Season Twelve: 12.22 “Who We Are”
Season Thirteen: 13.16 “Scoobynatural”
Season Fourteen: 14.13 “Lebanon”
Season Fifteen:  15.07 “Last Call”

Kimm Curran

Season One:  1.10 “Asylum”
Season Two:  2.06 “No Exit”
Season Three:  3.12 “Jus in Bello”
Season Four:  4.06 “Yellow Fever”
Season Five:  5.10 “Abandon All Hope”
Season Six:  6.11 “Appointment in Samarra”
Season Seven:  7.15 “Repo Man”
Season Eight:  8.23 “Sacrifice”
Season Nine:  9.04 “Slumber Party”
Season Ten:  10.14 “The Executioner’s Song”
Season Eleven:  11.04 “Baby”
Season Twelve:  12.11 “Regarding Dean”
Season Thirteen:  13.11 “Breakdown”
Season Fourteen:  14.02 “Prophet and Loss”
Season Fifteen:  15.03 “The Rupture”

Emberlast

 

Season One: 1.18 “Scarecrow” 
Season Two: 2.19 “Folsom Prison Blues” 
Season Three: 3.08 “A Very Supernatural Christmas” 
Season Four: 4.01 “Lazarus Rising” 
Season Five: 5.08 “Changing Channels” 
Season Six: 6.15 “The French Mistake”
Season Seven: 7.12 “Time After Time” 
Season Eight: 8.12 “As Time Goes By” 
Season Nine: 9.05 “Dog Dean Afternoon” 
Season Ten: 10.05 “Fan Fiction” 
Season Eleven: 11.04 “Baby” 
Season Twelve: 12.11 “Regarding Dean” 
Season Thirteen: 13.16 “Scoobynatural” 
Season Fourteen: 14.13 “Lebanon”
Season Fifteen: 15.19 “Inherit the Earth” 

Kate Provance

Season One: 1.12 “Faith”
Season Two: 2.15 “Tall Tales”
Season Three: 3.03 “Bad Day at Black Rock”
Season Four: 4.08 “Wishful Thinking”
Season Five: 5.12 “Swap Meat”
Season Six: 6.18 “Frontierland”
Season Seven: 7.14 “Plucky Pennywhistle’s Magical Menagerie”
Season Eight: 8.13 “Everybody Hates Hitler”
Season Nine: 9.05 “Dog Dean Afternoon”
Season Ten: 10.05 “Fan Fiction”
Season Eleven: 11.04 “Baby”
Season Twelve: 12.11 “Regarding Dean”
Season Thirteen: 13.19 “Funeralia”
Season Fourteen: 14.13 “Lebanon” 
Season Fifteen: 15.10 “The Heroes’ Journey”

Nate Winchester

Season One: 1.02 “Wendigo”
Season Two: 2.12 “Nightshifter”
Season Three: 3.12  “Jus In Bello”
Season Four: 4.03  “In the Beginning”
Season Five: 5.08 “Changing Channels”
Season Six: 6.09 “Clap Your Hands if you Believe”
Season Seven: 7.12 “Time After Time”
Season Eight: 8.12 “As Time Goes By”
Season Nine: 9.19 “Alex Annie Alexis Ann”
Season Ten: 10.05 “Fan Fiction”
Season Eleven: 11.04 “Baby”
Season Twelve: 12.12 “Stuck in the Middle (With You)”
Season Thirteen: 13.16 “Scoobynatural”
Season Fourteen: 14.13 “Lebanon”
Season Fifteen: 15.20 “Carry On”

Lilah Kane

Season One: 1.01 “Pilot”
Season Two: 2.20 “What Is and What Should Never Be”
Season Three: 3.11 “Mystery Spot”
Season Four: 4.01 “Lazarus Rising”
Season Five: 5.04 “The End”
Season Six: 6.15 “The French Mistake:
Season Seven: 7.10 “Death’s Door”
Season Eight: 8.13 “Everybody Hates Hitler”
Season Nine: 9.11 “First Born”
Season Ten: 10.12 “About a Boy”
Season Eleven: 11.16 “Safe House”
Season Twelve: 12.06 “Celebrating the Life of Asa Fox”
Season Thirteen: 13.16 “Scoobynatural”
Season Fourteen: 14.13 “Lebanon”
Season Fifteen: 15.11 “The Gamblers”

Alice

Season One: 1.09 “Home” 
Season Two: 2.12 “Nightshifter” 
Season Three: 3.11 “Mystery Spot”
Season Four: 4.21 “When the Levee Breaks” 
Season Five: 5.14 “My Bloody Valentine”
Season Six: 6.09 – “Clap Your Hands if You Believe” 
Season Seven: 7.02 – “Hello Cruel World” 
Season Eight: 8.21 “The Great Escapist” 
Season Nine: 9.22 “Do You Believe in Miracles?” 
Season Ten: 10.17 “The Inside Man” 
Season Eleven: 11.04 “Baby” 
Season Twelve: 12.22 “Who We Are”  
Season Thirteen: 13.16 “Scoobynatural”
Season Fourteen: 14.13 “Lebanon” 
Season Fifteen: 15.20 “Carry On” 

Okay everyone, your turn!  What are your choices?  If you can’t remember all the episodes, just check out our handy dandy Episode Guides of all seasons to help jog the memory.   

For all of you, there’s a bonus question!  Suppose you have the “Supernatural: The Complete Series” box set in front of you but still only have that one hour.  What would be that one “go to” episode for the entire series?  Share your answer in the comments along with your other picks.  

“Supernatural” Season 15 and “Supernatural: The Complete Series” come out on DVD and Blu-Ray on Tuesday, May 25th.  Order yours now!