Best Broment

Sam telling Dean that they need to seriously discuss about him going to the cage.
Best Sam Moment

Sam and Sully's heart to heart. Apologising, being hero's, being scared, the cage.
Best Dean Moment

Dean freeing himself and trying to talk Reese down from killing Sully.
Best Dean One Liners

Dean's one liners and facial expressions were endless and funny.
'Are you having a stroke? Do you smell toast?'
'I'm gonna get my gun'
'So he was a Manicorn'
'Find a giant toilet and flush her'
'Well he's no Clapton'
Best Puppy Dog Eyes

Sam confiding his worst fear.
Best Guest Actor Scene(s)

Sully (Nate Torrence) being there for Sam. What a loveable character.
Grossest Moment

Mom unknowingly smearing Manicorn blood on her face. " She's got Sparkle on her face"
Creepiest Moment

I'm sorry but the Manicorn kind of creep me out.
Best Nostalgic Moment

Seeing Dylan Everett returning as young Dean
Saddest Moment

Young Sam sending Sully away. "Pretend friend! You're not real"
Best Alias

Grief Counsellors. Loved the sweaters.
Funniest Moment

Dean not able to see who Sam is threatening.

Dean's reaction to seeing Sully. "You mean Mork from Ork here is your dumbass imaginary friend Sully"
"What the...?" Moment

Waking up at 6:30 am when you don't have too.
Best Camera Shot

A table full of treats in the foreground while an unaware Sam shuffles back and forth to make the coffee.
Best Yummy Moment

Mmmmmm ... Sweet Tooth Heaven
Best Parental Moment

Dean in daddy mode - "You and Me, Library Right Now! Come on!"
Sam in child mode - Hanging head, slumped shoulders and shuffling of feet.
I hope you enjoyed this week's "Memorable Moments" review! Please share what your picks would be for these categories, or offer categories of your own!
Comments
I liked Sully and was relieved he survived the episode. ;)
The J's really did a great job of looking like they just woke up didn't they.
As for the Dad mode, I understand what you're saying and your suggestion probably would have been better received. I almost didn't put that in, but for me it worked. I found it kind of a cute moment. The way Sam was so bewildered over Sully being real, I wasn't surprised that Dean got frustrated and took control. However I loved that once Sam was out of the kitchen he was back in full control of himself.
Thank you so much for sharing your thoughts.
I really like this episode as well. It is hard to narrow some of the moments down when there is so many. I usually go by what stood out the most and go with that one.
I'm so happy your enjoying these. :) I really like doing them.
Thank you so much for your comments.
Thanks for another great post!I really liked this episode and I think your choices were perfect!
Dean's one liners and facial expressions were golden and so funny! I loved his daddy mood and Sam's reaction to it!all in all fun moments were awesome! And the moment Dean talked about not being there for Sam was SO emotional and I really felt for Dean!
Also for Sam,his talks with Sully were really beautiful and I was proud of him for facing his worst fears!I really liked his flash backs too!
And let's not forget the great moment you mentioned too!Dylan's return as Young!Dean made me so happy! I also liked Young!Sam too!
Thanks!!!
I loved Dean's one liners and his expressions. The J's are so fantastic at their facial expressions. Just one look and you know exactly what their feeling or expressing.
Thank you for sharing your thoughts.....Ch eers!