Most Gratuitous/Totally Sexy Moment of Supernatural Season 11
Winner
Sam and Dean in their sleepwear in the kitchen (gotta love Dean still wearing the dead guy robe) – “Just My Imagination”
Runner-Up
An infected Sam playing MacGyver – “Form and Void”
Yeah, the choices were kind of lame this year. Even when Sam got laid in “Baby,” it was all off camera. But two Winchesters in their sleepwear encountering an imaginary friend in their kitchen? It wasn’t much, but we’ll take what we can get.
Editor’s choice
An infected Sam playing MacGyver – “Form and Void”
What can I say. I’m a sucker for Hurt!Sam AND Smart!Sam
Best Plot of Supernatural Season 11
Winner
A whole episode from the Impala’s POV – “Baby”
Runners-Up
Sam is shot and badly wounded in the remote wilderness while he, Dean, and two other victims are being hunted by werewolves – “Red Meat”
Parallel stories of Bobby/Rufus and Sam/Dean hunting the same ghost years apart – “Safe House”
The voting between the top three was pretty close.
Editor’s Choice
Parallel stories of Bobby/Rufus and Sam/Dean hunting the same ghost years apart – “Safe House”
As much as I loved “Baby”, I found that to be more of an ideal concept that everyone got to run with, especially the production team. It wasn’t really a big plot. I loved “Red Meat” too but I thought the plot of “Safe House” was more clever and more complex. Weaving together stories like that is not easy! Plus we finally got the “Grumpy Old Men of Letters” line.
Worst Plot of Supernatural Season 11
Winner
Vampires again? Claire again? – “Don’t You Forget About Me”
Runners-Up
Supercharged cicada type mutant monsters? Um no. – “The Chitters”
Sam and Dean solve a case with wrestlers – “Beyond the Mat”
Again, the voting was pretty close in this category, at least for the three choices up above.
Editor’s Choice
Supercharged cicada type mutant monsters? Um no. – “The Chitters”
If you’re going to run with a MOTW story, make the monsters creepy please. Taking on the mutant type creatures that essentially went nowhere? Not even a big kill? The only thing that elevates the “Don’t You Forget About Me” plot in my mind is the return of the most awesome Jody Mills.
Best Use of Classic Rock/Any Music in Supernatural Season 11
Winner
“Night Moves” by Bob Seger – “Baby”
Runner Up
“Fare Thee Well” sung by Rob Benedict – “Don’t Call Me Shurley”
These were the two stand out musical moments of “Supernatural” Season 11, bar none. It was kind of cruel making people choose between one or the other, wasn’t it? “Night Moves” still won with 40% of the vote over “Fare The Well’s” 29%, and “Heaven Must Be Missing An Angel” got 17%. The other choices barely registered.
Editor’s Choice
“Night Moves” by Bob Seger – “Baby”
I’m a Detroiter born and raised, and Mr. Seger is our native son. I’ve always wanted to hear this song on the show and the use couldn’t have been more perfect. Out in the back seat of the ’67 Chevy indeed!
Coming up tomorrow, the WFB staff choice awards! Well, just a couple of us writers with some opinions, because we have them.
Leave a Reply