Caption This! Winners #1-50 #1 Episode 10.23 – “Brother’s Keeper” Winner – guest#2 Episode 9.20 – “Bloodlines” Winner – Jen#3 Episode 8.12 – “As Time Goes By” Winner (tie) – Karen & samandean10#3 Episode 8.12 – “As Time Goes By” Winner (tie) – Karen & samandean10#4 Episode 2.18 – “Hollywood Babylon” Winner – Karen#5 Episode 3.11 – “Mystery Spot” Winner – Lilah_Kane#6 Episode 1.13 – “Route 666” Winner – Suzkatoon75#7 Episode 3.06 – “Red Sky at Morning” Winner – samandean10#8 Episode 4.14 – “Sex and Violence” Winner – Lilah_Kane#9 Episode 9.12 – “Swap Meat” Winner – guest#10 Episode 6.18 – “Frontierland” Winner – Lilah_Kane#11 Episode 7.16 – “Out With the Old” Winner – Sheebie#12 Episode 1.01 – “Pilot” Winner – JD#13 Episode 11.01 – “Out of the Darkness, Into the Fire” Winner – Leah#14 Episode 11.02 – “Form and Void” Winner (tie) – samandean10 & guest#14 Episode 11.02 – “Form and Void” Winner (tie) – samandean10 & guest#15 Episode 11.03 – “The Bad Seed” Winner – AlyCat22#16 Episode 11.04 – “Baby” Winner – samandean10#17 Episode 11.05 – “Thin Lizzie” Winner – samandean10#18 Episode 11.06 – “Our Little World” Winner – Jasper#19 Episode 11.07 – “Plush” Winner – cheryl42#20 Episode 4.06 – “Yellow Fever” Winner – samandean10#21 Episode 11.08 – “Just My Imagination” Winner – AlyCat22#22 Episode 11.09 – “O Brother Where art Thou?” Winner – Lilah_Kane#23 Episode 9.13 – “The Purge” Winner – samandean10#24 Episode 6.14 – “Mannequin 3: the Reckoning” Winner – FiercelyNormal#25 Episode 7.08 – “Season Seven, Time for a Wedding” Winner – Karen#26 Episode 8.19 – “Taxi Driver” Winner – cheryl42#27 Episode 11.10 – “The Devil in the Details” Winner – AlyCat22#28 Episode 11.11 – “Into the Mystic” Winner (tie) – blsedbx3 & AlyCat22#28 Episode 11.11 – “Into the Mystic” Winner (tie) – blsedbx3 & AlyCat22#29 Episode 11.12 – “Don’t You Forget About Me” Winner – Karen#30 Episode 11.13 – “Love Hurts” Winner – LEAH#31 Episode 11.14 – “The Vessel” Winner – blsedbx3#32 Episode 11.15 – “Beyond the Mat” Winner – elif#33 Episode 10.16 – “Paint it Black” Winner – blsedbx3#34 Episode 5.06 – “I Believe the Children Are Our Future” Winner – blsedbx3#35 Episode 2.09 – “Croatoan” Winner (tie) – elif & blsedbx3#35 Episode 2.09 – “Croatoan” Winner (tie) – elif & blsedbx3#36 Episode 11.16 – “Safe House” Winner – Lilah_Kane#37 Episode 11.17 – “Red Meat” Winner – samandean10 & @cdekker_22#38 Episode 11.18 – “Hell’s Angel” Winner – AlyCat22#39 Episode 1.12 – “Faith” Winner – blsedbx3#40 Episode 11.19 – “The Chitters” Winner – blsedbx3#41 Episode 11.20 – “Don’t Call Me Shurley” Winner – AlyCat22#42 Episode 11.21 – “All in the Family” Winner – blsedbx3#43 Episode 11.22 – “We Happy Few” Winner – LEAH#44 Episode 11.23 – “Alpha and Omega” Winner – cheryl42#45 Episode 2.20 – “What is and What Shall Never Be” Winner – AlyCat22#46 Episode 3.08 – “A Very Supernatural Christmas” Winner – cheryl42#48 Episode 5.08 – “Changing Channels” Winner – Lilah_kane#49 Episode 6.15 – “The French Mistake” Winner – blsdbex3#50 Episode 7.10 – “Death’s Door” Winner – Katherine CainShare on FacebookTweetFollow usSave