Caption This! 441 – The Other Brothers Edition
Welcome to another week of caption this! Last week was a little chaotic and we missed posting a new contest. Blame me, I decided to go take a week long vacation in warm weather. Sorry, but not sorry!
Also, apologies for all the confusion on contest #440 and the looks back at the previous winners we started posting. Let me explain the intent. Caption #440, aka the Reverse Caption This, was meant to be a friendly little contest between Nate and myself. We each submitted a caption from the first Supernatural episode we watched. Nate’s first episode was “Wendigo” where mine was “All Hell Breaks Loose Part II”. The purpose was for all of you to pick the winner.
This one was from Nate:

And this one was from me:

Based on the two votes that were cast, Nate is the winner! So congrats Nate. I would have voted for him too. I’m a sucker for Bugs Bunny.
As for the captions that were also submitted for fun, I did enjoy reading through all of them! But cheryl42, you really outdid both Nate and I, by a lot. Both of these were just pure brilliance! I especially am kicking myself for my caption. Why didn’t I think of this? Yours is so much better. These are two captions I will want to keep handy for future installments where I have to explain Supernatural in a few sentences:

We are also going to start posting, 50 contests at a time, a look back at all our Caption This! winners. Since this game has been going on so long, we thought it would be fun to look back at all the insane creativity and overall brilliant humor we’ve been blessed with. We will invite anyone to share which are your favorites if you’d like, but there’s no contest involved. The winning was already done!
Okay, now for this week’s installment. I watched the season three premiere of Tracker this week. This is a one part of a two part episode where Jensen is back as the most awesome Russell Shaw, older brother to Justin Hartley’s Colter Shaw. This episode was amazing! It just goes to show, Jensen knows how to do the brotherly act. I’m not saying these two are better than Sam and Dean, but man they are so freaking fun to watch. How would you caption this pair of brothers?
![]()
I love having fun with brothers with strange looks on their faces! I even recently created a new Supernatural Motivational Poster when I saw this picture while fixing our archives:

So, how would you caption this? Brothers Shaw for the win I say, so I don’t see this going too wrong. Go ahead and make me and Nate laugh! Or cry, or just go “Awww…” Anything will work.
Instructions on How to Enter
Scroll all the way down to Disqus below:
Click on one of the icons to log in with an existing social media account (Discord, Facebook, X, Google, etc) or click the “Name” box that is next to all the icons. It will bring up the following screen:
There you can create a Disqus account, or you can check “I’d rather post as a guest” (that small check box after the 5 terms and conditions) and provide a screen name (that will be posted with your caption) and your email address (which will NOT be posted. It just keeps out all the spam responses). Enter your Caption in the “Join the Discussion” text box then hit the arrow to submit.
Here are the past winners:
Okay, time to Caption This!

Alice Jester is the founder, editor-in-chief, head writer, programmer, web designer, site administrator, marketer, and moderator for The Winchester Family Business. She is a 30 year IT applications and database expert with a penchant for creative and freelance writing in her spare (ha!!) time. That’s on top of being a wife, mother of two active kids, and four loving (aka needy) pets.



Leave a Reply