Sorry for the delay. There were... incidents last time so the contest featuring Henriksen and Dean got extended a bit. Hope nobody minded.
And for that contest, it seems we had some telepathy going on as several folks all came up with the same words. Which I count as votes so congrats to our co-winners, AlyCat22, Joan Phillips, and Vicki Fisher (from facebook). I even think some twitter people may have uttered those words.
So I see now we are up to the tie with #44 on our top 100 list, episode 6.20 "The Man Who Would be King." I must admit, I love Edlund episodes. Almost every frame is filled with captionable material. Hard to go wrong with Crowley and Castiel.
The first 50 winning entries are here. Winning entries numbered 51-100 are here. The winners of 101-150 are here. And 151-200 are now here. Winners #201-250 will be coming soon.