First of all, in a WFB first, I am awarding to @Superunditchabl a pun award for "Sammy, what do you call a frog that's parked illegally? Toad."
Several of you had some great puns, including an anonymous guest who posted at the last minute, but that one elicited the biggest groan.
As for the actual winner of the previous contest, congrats to AlyCat22 who made me chuckle with a meta reference.
This time we're back in season 4, looking at episode 4.04 "Metamorphisis" with the boys chilling out with another hunter that's not long for this world.
The first 50 winning entries are here. Winning entries numbered 51-100 are here. The winners of 101-150 are here. And 151-200 are now here.