Ok I’m back with four more episode titles and have put my thoughts on each.
What are your thoughts on the following episodes?
Is it a scene, a moment, a line or song?
And why? It is your favourite or is it the emotional impact it has on you?
Maybe it simply makes you laugh or hide under the covers.
What Is and What Should Never Be


This was a powerful episode. There are so many moments with this one. Dean’s memorable speech at his dad gravesite, how strained his relationship was with Sam. How everyone keeps asking if he’s been drinking. But the moment that affected me the most was Deans first moments with his mother. When Mary opens the door and seeing Deans face it’s so heart wrenching and when he hugs her. And how he leaned into her hand when she places it gently on his face, the way he embraced her loving touch. It was all so beautifully done.
No Rest for the Wicked

For this one the scene that always comes to me first is when Dean and Sam are in the house searching for Lilith, however time is running out and Sam gets desperate, demanding Ruby tell him what he needs to do to bring on his powers. Dean tells Sam no. Sam is now in tears.

Dean: I know this is all my fault and I’m sorry, but what you’re doing isn’t going to save me and it’s only going to kill you.
Sam: Then what am I supposed to do?
Dean: Keep fighting. Take care of my wheels. Remember what Dad taught you. Remember what I taught you.
Dean grins at Sam with tears running down his own face.
The time hits midnight and chimes.
Ruby: Sorry Dean, I wouldn’t wish this on my worst enemy.
In The Beginning

I have two scenes with this episode. The first one is Dean’s last talk with Mary. She is listening to music and Dean comes into the room to say good-bye.

Dean: It doesn’t matter what your dad thinks. I like that John kid. I think you two are meant to be, hell I’m depending on it. What’s John like?
Mary: He’s sweet, kind, even after the war, after everything he still believes in happily ever after. He’s everything a hunter isn’t. No offense. He’s gonna ask me to marry him tomorrow I think. Oh Dad’s going to explode but I don’t care. I’ll run away if I have to. I love John. I wanna get out this job, this life, I hate it. I want a family. I want to be safe. You know the very worst thing I can think of? Is for my family to be raised into this like I was. I won’t let it happen!
(Dean is tearing up). Hey you Ok?
Dean: Yeah. Even if this sounds really weird will you promise me that you will remember? On November 2nd 1983, don’t get out of bed? Now matter what you hear or what you see, promise me you won’t get out of bed. (Tears fall down Dean’s face)
Mary: Ok.

The second is when Dean is too late to stop Mary from making the deal with Yellow Eyes and Castiel shows up to take Dean back to present time. The compassion on Cas’s face was equally as heartbreaking as the anguished expression on Deans.
How To Win Friends and Influence Monsters

I have two moments with this episode.  The first one is the forest scene with Sam, Dean and Bobby, when they are talking about hunting as children.

Sam: I guess I forgot before you were a hunter you were actually a Hunter.
Bobby: We shot our dinner when I was a kid.
Dean: You used to take us hunting when we were kids. Dad had a case, he’d just dump us on you. You must have taught us most of the outdoor tracking we knew.
Bobby: What I could get to stick. Never could get you grubs to pull the trigger on a single deer.
Dean: You’re talking about Bambi man.
Bobby: You don’t shoot Bambi, Jackass. You shoot Bambi’s mother.
Sam frowns and shakes his head.
The second one is when Sam clues in that there is something wrong with the sandwich that Dean is eating and they take it back to the cabin.

Dean: This is stupid the sandwich didn’t do anything. I don’t know what you think you’re going to find.
Bobby: There is something wrong with you Dean.
Dean: Are you kidding? I’m fine. I actually feel great, best I’ve felt in a couple of months. Cas, Black goo, I don’t even care anymore. You know what’s even better?  I don’t care that I don’t care. I just want my damn Slammer back!
Sam: You’re completely stoned just like Ranger Rick was.
Bobby: Just like the dinner rush back at Biggerson’s and everybody’s lovin’ the Turducken.
Deans sandwich suddenly blurbs out gray goo.
Dean: I think you pissed off my sandwich. That’s in me?
Sam: Only half of it.
Bobby: Does that snot look familiar? So whatever turned Gerald Browder into a pumpkin head is currently turning Dean into an idiot.
Dean: I’m right here. Right here.
Bobby: Is in the Turducken sandwich at Biggerson’s, it’s in the meat
Dean: If I wasn’t chilled out right now I would puke.

What's your favorite scene from these episodes?