Well, we were uninamous, but that's not necessarily good. All four of us at the TV Fanatic Roundtable, myself, Nightsky, Christine Laskodi and Sean McKenna, all pretty much though "There's Something About Mary" was crap. We all thought that Eileen's death was pointless and handled poorly, and we aren't very pleased the way Mary and Crowley's characters have been butchered. On the plus side, there is some awesome opportunity now for a rat/hamster romance. The fan fiction writes itself.
Here's Sean McKenna's review. He gave it 2.1 out of 5.0. Trust me when I say, that is super low for him. He was not happy with this one.