It's really funny how Nightsky and I seem to be on opposite sides of the spectrum when it comes to analyzing "Supernatural." That's not a bad thing, that's what makes us unique and entertaining, but I always find it interesting how the roundtable format really shows those differences. That's especially true for our roundtable for "The Memory Remains." She and I were in agreement on a couple of points, but we were on opposite ends for the others. Sean McKenna and Christine Laskodi of TV Fanatic had their own opinions too, giving some good variety to this particular roundtable.
Sean McKenna, like myself, was a real fan of this episode. Here's his review which praises the fact that we got an actual Sam and Dean MOTW story and it was back to basics, like Sam working on the lore and Dean working on the ladies. He finds this type of story more intriguing than the crap we have been getting with the British Men of Letters. Once again, I'm in total agreement! All in all, he gave this episode a 4.3 out of 5.0.