So who was truly creeped out by all the masks in "Plush?"  I know all four of us at this week's TV Fanatic Roundtable had a few things to say about that.  Myself and Nightsky, along with TV Fanatic's Sean McKenna and Christine Laskodi, also talked about our favorite scene, the return of Sheriff Donna, and whether Sam will actually listen to Dean's and forget about the cage (HA!).  It all can be found here:

For some extra reading, since this is a break week and you're probably using it for some catch up, here's Sean McKenna's review.  He was like me, he didn't find this one to be all that great.  He gave it a 3.4 out of 5.0.