Article Index

Welcome back to "Top Six Favourite Episodes", this time for season eleven. These are, still to this day, the nearest and dearest to my heart, my comfort episodes, the ones I go to when I need a laugh or a cry or the comfort of an old friend. 

Before you read my list, make your own list of season 11 favourites! It will be fun to compare your unbiased choices (before you are unduly influenced by my memories or picks) to mine. If you regularly rewatch the series from the beginning (on Netflix, with TNT TV or on DVD), or if you followed the Supernatural Top 100 Episode Countdown that The Winchester Family Business unveiled during the 2019 hiatus, these episode should be fresh in your mind!!  Nightsky reveals her Top 6 season 11 favourites after mine, so you'll have two WFB staff lists as a comparison! 

So without further ado, here's my list of Season Eleven Favourites!  The list is by order of appearance only, as they all are equal in their importance to me. For season 11, you may notice that I have episodes 1 & 2  joined as one episode. Since two is continued from one, I figured I could cheat a little!

"Out of the Darkness into the Fire" (Part 1)

Darkness with Dean 225

After the Darkness is released, she takes Dean to thank him.     

SPN 0095

Meanwhile, Sam wakes up and searches for Dean, who he eventually finds passed out in the field.      

SPN 0456

While heading home, they come across a construction site. The workers are all dead, plus a family in a car. However, one worker survived and seems to be infected with a virus that made them all go crazy.  

Supernatural S11E01 1080p kissthemgoodbye net 0825

When the worker attacks the brothers, he is shot by Deputy Jenna Nickerson. She responded to a 911 call and found the workers attacking the family. She managed to kill the deranged attackers but was wounded in the process.                       

SPN 0611

Sam and Dean take Jenna to the hospital, but find almost everyone dead there, too. 


They find survivor Mike and his newborn Amara. Unfortunately he is also infected and gives his daughter to Jenna to care for, as he know he doesn't have long to live. 

SPN 1096

The hospital gets invaded by more infected people. Dean and Jenna  leave with Amara to find a safer place while Sam stays to find a cure.   

normal spn1101 2463

Sam ends up getting attacked and is now infected. He doesn't tell Dean when he calls for an update. Sam is determined to find a cure. 

Cas in Barn 92

Meanwhile, Cas is dealing with the animal spell Rowena put on him....    

SPN 0800

...and Crowley had to find another meat suit, until his old one was released from Rowena's immobilization spell. 

"Form and Void" (Part 2)

SPN 0103

Dean takes Jenna and Amara to Jenna's grandmother's home. 

SPN 0453

Jenna and Grandma witness Amara's abilities....          

normal spn1102 0848

... and needs.        


Grandma is a little freaked out by Amara and calls for a priest, Father Crowley.        

s11e02 407

While Dean and Father Crowley go out to discuss the situation..... 

SPN 1214

Jenna becomes soulless from Amara feeding off of her and Jenna kills her grandma.  

s11e02 136

As for Sam, he is getting as much information from other infected people so he can find a cure.  

SPN 0874

After feeling despondent, he goes to the chapel and prays for Dean to survive.   

SPN 0654

Sam is then introduced to Reaper Billie who informs him that his time is near and he won't be coming back. She also gives him a little hint that he won't be going to Heaven as he is unclean in the biblical sense.        

CuringSam 470

After some time, Sam figures out the cure is heating the virus out with holy oil.       



"A Day In The Life Of Baby"

spn1104 0127

Getting pampered with a wash and blow dry.        

s11e04 109

Enjoying good tunes .....                               

s11e04 117

....  listening in on the light conversations and banter....                                                      

11.04 204

... as well as the more serious talks.                      

normal Baby 339

Providing a safe place to sleep, being a home for the night.      

s11e04 306

Some down falls do happen .... being hi-jacked and taken for a joy ride.          

normal Baby 691

Having fights from the inside...      

s11e04 367

... and those on the outside.             

s11e04 591

Enduring the battle scars.                


Or worse, seeing those you love endure battle wounds.     

"Into The Mystic"

normal Into the mystic 030

A flash back 30 years ago in Cork, Ireland, were a couple is killed....

S11E11 57 

by a Banshee.   

s11e11 49

Their little daughter survives but her ear drums burst from the Banshee's wail.   


Back to present day where Sam can't sleep due to nightmares of his time with Lucifer.     

s11e11 113

The brothers investigate a strange death at an retirement home.    

s11e11 k15

They find out the victim was stealing Viagra pills. As Sam reads the victim's profile, Dean casually pockets one of the prescriptions.                              

s11e11 325 mildred close up

That evening, the manager is attacked and killed by the Banshee. The attack is witnessed by one of the residents, Mildred.                

s11e11 k31

Dean interviews Mildred and finds she a little extra friendly.                


Sam investigates Eileen and finds out she is also a hunter and was..... 

s11e11 k27

... the infant who lost her hearing and her parents to the Banshee years ago.                    


Dean goes back to the bunker to get the gold blades they need to kill the Banshee and finds Cas there. Dean is still unaware that Cas is possessed by Lucifer.             

s11e11 460

Dean goes back to the home and waits with Mildred, ...                       

s11e11 427

....Sam and Eileen for the return of the Banshee.                          


When the Banshee arrives, it is Dean that is affected instead of Mildred.              


Mildred and......                              

s11e11 509 Eileens kill

Eileen are able to kill the Banshee.                                          

normal Into the mystic 580

As Sam and Dean leave ...                

normal Into the mystic 582

... they are watched on by some adoring fans.   

Click "Next" for 3 More Favs, Plus Nightsky's Choices!

"Safe House"

spn1116 0372

Sam and Dean investigate a child going into a suspicious coma.                                            

s11e16 90

spn1116 0573

Bobby and Rufus worked on a similar case at the same home.                                      

spn1116 0262

Both mothers from today and .....                  

spn1116 0692

...the past recount the same strange occurrences  leading up to their child's coma's.               

spn1116 1153

Sam and Dean go to salt and burn two possible vengeful spirits, but....  

spn1116 1110

...find they had already been burned by Bobby and Rufus.                                                 

spn1116 1547

Knowing that it's not a spirit, Bobby and Rufus do further research.            

spn1116 1551

Sam and Dean do the same.                                                  

spn1116 2500

Both teams finally realise they are dealing with a Soul Eater.                               

spn1116 2254

Rufus and Bobby find a way to trap the Soul Eater, however, Bobby gets pulled into the nest.        

s11e16 442

Sam and Dean find a way to kill the Soul Eater, however, Dean needs to be in the nest to do so.             

Safe house 540

Rufus is able to trap the Soul Eater.                         

spn1116 2757

And Sam is able to kill it.                                    


While both are still in the nest, Bobby and ....


....Dean have a moment where they see each other before being released.            

spn1116 2830

Rufus comforts Bobby.                                  

11.16 2847

Sam comforts Dean.     


"Red Meat"


Sam and Dean investigate the disappearance of a newlywed couple, Corbin and Michelle.            

spn1117 0036

They find the couple held captive in a cabin by Werewolves. During their rescue, Sam is shot.       

spn1117 0482

As the couple and the brothers make the long journey back to the car, Sam's health is failing. They come across a ranger's cabin and seek refuge.      


Corbin tries to convince Dean that they can't stay there and that Sam should be left behind. Dean won't hear of it and goes out to find wood to make a litter (stretcher) for Sam.            

spn1117 0800

While Dean is gone, Corbin suffocates Sam and kills him.                             

RM 6

When Dean returns, Corbin lies and says Sam just died. Dean is heartbroken but realises they have to leave and get to safety.              

spn1117 1324

Once rescued by a deputy, Corbin tries to convince Michelle that everything is going to be okay. However Michelle is unsure of Corbin since finding out he killed Sam.                               

spn1117 1992

Corbin transforms into a Werewolf.                                                  

spn1117 2072

Dean overdoses on pills so he can make a deal with a Reaper to bring back Sam.                             

RM 11

Billie shows up to reap Dean and informs him that Sam is not dead.  Before Billie could take Dean, he is revived by the doctor.                                                      

spn1117 2586

Sam manages to get back to the car and contacts Dean to warn him about Corbin, however the signal is weak and they get cut off.                            

spn1117 2830

Sam makes it to the hospital in time to save Dean from Corbin.                             

RM 16

Later, Dean tries to console Michelle but she doesn't see how she will ever get over what she has seen.       

spn1117 3054

Sam and Dean head home.               

"Don't Call Me Shurley"

Don t call me shurley 015

While Metatron is looking for food in a dumpster to feed himself and his four legged friend... 

spn1120 0076

....he and his friend get transported to a bar.                                               

11.20 158 chuck

He finds Chuck there.                             

Don t call me shurley 067

Chuck reveals himself to be God.  He wants Metatron to edit his manuscript.                                                 

spn1120 0783

An inpatient God/Chuck is eager to find out Metatron's opinion.                         

spn1120 0355

Meanwhile, as Dean irons Sam's shirt with beer, Sam informs Dean of a possible case that may lead them to Amara.             


During their investigation of the deceased, they notice the same virus from earlier.    

Don t call me shurley 383

Another victim of the virus arrives to give a warning to Dean from Amara.          

11.20 445 Fog in town

The fog carrying the virus arrives at the town.                            

11.20 440 Sam and Baby

Sam and Dean help rush everyone inside to safety.                           

Don t call me shurley 519

However, they are unable to stop the fog from entering the building.                  

11.20 536 Dean yelling

As Sam starts to succumb to the fog, Dean realises he's immune and yells up to God. "Stop this! You hear me you dick!"                     

spn1120 2963

Back at the bar, a proud God/Chuck finishes his manuscript.     

spn1120 3036

He gives the script to Metatron to read as he plays and sings a powerful version of 'Fare Thee Well'. A montage of events happen as he sings.                        

Don t call me shurley 584

We see Dean hanging on to his dying brother....  

11.20 566 Glowing Amulet

when suddenly a glowing light comes from Sam's jacket pocket. It is the amulet.  The fog disperses and everyone starts recovering.  

Don t call me shurley 629

Metatron finishes the final pages and looks upon God/Chuck with a bereft expression.               

11.20 576 SD Amulet 1

Sam and Dean head out, following the glow of the amulet.                          

11.20 597 WeShouldTalk

They finally come upon Chuck/God who looks to the boys and says, "We should probably talk."               

Those are my top favourites for season eleven! As promised, here are Nightsky's "Top 6 Favourite Episodes" for season eleven, in order of preference:

  1.  "Don't Call Me Shurley"
  2.  "Baby"
  3.  "Just My Imagination"
  4.  "O Brother, Where Art Thou?"
  5.  "The Devil in the Details"
  6.  "Red Meat"

Nightsky: Just like season 10, there were a lot of great episodes in season 11! Supernatural was on a roll! My top 6 choices for season 11 were all in my top 51 ("Red Meat" was 51) favorites for the series, as ranked for the Top 100 countdown last year, if that tells you the comparative quality of these episodes. "Safe House", "The Vessel" and "All in the Family" were my next three favorites, still all within the top 100 of the series thus far. 

Now it's your turn!  Which episodes make your top 6? What surprised you, either by inclusion or exclusion, from my or Nightsky's lists? Make your lists now, if you didn't before you read our favorites, then compare to where the episodes fall in WFB's Ultimate Top 100 Hiatus Challenge!

Having fun comparing favorites? Keep going with season 12's list! If you missed seeing our earlier lists, catch up by starting with Top 6 Favourite Episodes, Supernatural Season 1! Each season has a link to the next season's list! You can follow along through the entire series, start with a specific season, or enjoy The WFB's many other Supernatural Top 10 lists, always available on our Tags Page!

Please share your thoughts below!