Largest Review/Discussion Fansite for Supernatural and SPNFamily Shows! Plot/Character Analysis, Spoilers, Games, News, Gallery, Interviews, Fun!

Welcome back to "Top Six Favourite Episodes", this time for season three. These are still, to this day, the nearest and dearest to my heart, my comfort episodes, the ones I go to when I need a laugh or a cry or the comfort of an old friend. 

Before you read my list, make your own list of season 3 favorites! It will be fun to compare your unbiased choices (before you are unduly influenced by my memories or picks) to mine.  If you're joining Nightsky and The WFB in the #SPNSummer2019 Rewatch, or rewatching at your own pace this hiatus, the episodes should be fresh in your mind! Save your list then, because you'll need it for TOP 100 Episode challenge that The Winchester Family Business unveiled last week! Nightsky reveals her Top 6 season 3 favorites after mine, so you'll have two WFB staff lists as a comparison!

So without further ado, here's my list of Season Three Favourites! The list is by order of appearance only, as they all are equal in their importance to me. 

1) "Bad Day at Black Rock"


Sam and Dean go to John's  storage unit and find old family treasures.                               


Sam takes hold of a possessed rabbit's foot,       


which brings him good luck, until it gets stolen from him.                     


Sam loses his shoe down a drain.         


When Dean asks what's wrong, Sam replies with 'I lost my shoe'       


and then pouts.     


He also catches on fire.                              


We get the return of Gordon,                   


and this was the introduction to Bela.             


2) "Sin City"


Ruby helps Bobby fix the colt...                                       


...and Bobby tests it out by shooting Ruby.               


Dean and Casey get trapped, and he and we ....                        


....learn the back story of Yellow Eyes/ Azazel.           


Dean walks by a parked limo with a woman coaxing Dean to join her....


...however Sam gets Dean back on the case. 


The motel was pretty kinky with mirrored ceiling and ......                        


...Dean's favourite "Magic Fingers."       


3) "Fresh Blood"

vlcsnap 00031

Gordon becomes a Vampire.    


Sam's heartfelt talk with Dean,                

vlcsnap 00052

and Dean listening and understanding his brother's feelings.         

vlcsnap 00076

A scary Sam and how he kills Gordon.          

vlcsnap 00079

Sam seems at little shocked by what he was able to do.                  

vlcsnap 00087

The end scene was another great brotherly moment with Dean working on the car while Sam helps.                        

vlcsnap 00093

Dean decides it's time to teach Sam how to look after the Impala.  

vlcsnap 00096

So now Sam takes over working on the Impala while Dean sits and enjoys a cold one.  

4) "A Very Supernatural Christmas"

5 christmas

We get to see a lonely Christmas that Sam and Dean had as children,       

spn308 0612

and when Sam finds out about monsters.          

vlcsnap 00158

We also learn how Dean got his amulet.                       


The pagan Gods Madge and Edward were quite the experience,      

vlcsnap 00122

including their tortuous rituals.        

vlcsnap 00162

A touching moment at the end when Sam gives Dean a Christmas.    


The brothers exchange gifts.                                      

vlcsnap 00182

I loved the end shot with Sam and Dean watching the game in the motel room and with the Impala outside guarding over her boys.   


5) "Mystery Spot"

vlcsnap 00021

Who would have thought that an episode that has Dean dying many deaths could be entertaining...  

vlcsnap 00031

... Mind you the first death was quite shocking ....            

vlcsnap 00033

...especially to Sam.  But after the 'Ground Hog Day' effect begins,

vlcsnap 00091

... Dean being crushed by a desk......

vlcsnap 00103

....slipping in the shower......       

vlcsnap 00108

..... and being electrocuted becomes more comical , as we know it won't last forever.             

vlcsnap 00127

It isn't just Dean's death but also actions and conversations that are funny, where Sam knows exactly what Dean is going to say.    

vlcsnap 00152

We find out 'Ground Hog Day' is being controlled by the Trickster.   

vlcsnap 00167

Unfortunately, the Trickster has Dean die permanently.             

vlcsnap 00188

We see Sam living stoically, hunting non-stop, stitching his own wounds, but seeing him eat with an additional plate of food set out, knowing that it's for Dean, we see that he is deeply hurting.      

vlcsnap 00230

Sam's hug to Dean when he finally returns ......

vlcsnap 00231

 is adorable and heartbreaking.                           

vlcsnap 00243

Sam's expression as they are finally able to leave the motel, shows how emotionally devastated Sam is by this experience.   


6) "No Rest for the Wicked"


Until the bitter end, Bobby is at their side...   "Family don't end with blood."           


We have a light moment of the brothers singing along to Bon Jovi's 'Wanted Dead or Alive".    

3x16 0522

We meet a very scary Lilith.                        


Sam defeats Lilith who is now possessing Ruby's body.               


Tragic end to Dean and Sam crying over his death.                      


Dean in hell crying for Sam.  

Those are my top favourites for season three! As promised, here are Nightsky's "Top 6 Favourite Episodes" for season three, in order of preference:

  1.  "No Rest for the Wicked"
  2.  "Mystery Spot"
  3.  "Jus in Bello"
  4.  "Bad Day at Black Rock"
  5.  "A Very Supernatural Christmas"
  6.  "Dream a Little Dream of Me" 

Now it's your turn!  Which episodes make your top 6? What surprised you, either by inclusion or exclusion, from my or Nightsky's lists? Make your lists now, if you didn't before you read our favorites. You're going to need them for WFB's Ultimate Top 100 Hiatus Challenge!

Having fun? Keep going with our Top 6 Favourite Episodes, Supernatural Season 4!

If you missed seeing our earlier lists, catch up on:
Top 6 Favourite Episodes, Supernatural Season 1, and
Top 6 Favourite Episodes, Supernatural Season 2

Enjoy The WFB's many other Supernatural Top 10 lists, always available on our Tags Page!

Please share your thoughts below!