Misha Collins as Lucifer

I know many of you would give this the worst award, but I think the idea was half baked.  The writing often pure ass, that's for sure.  The performance was not.  He did an amazing job. 

“Plush”

Who thought it was a good idea to give Sam the Roger Rabbit, "You were framed" line?  There the writers go reversing Sam and Dean lines again.  I half expected this to happen next.  

"Hell's Angel"

Oh, there were a few l, but I wasn’t quite expecting this to happen when the Scooby Gang had another one of their schemes in the church. 

Best...Exorcism…Ever

Stunt Demon #3 and Stunt Angel #4

Wait, that happened in  “The Bad Seed?”  Okay, there’s something I do remember about that episode after all.  It’s a scene I’ve been dying to see since season four.  But alas, the angel was toasted by Amara in “O’ Brother Where Art Thou?”  Couldn’t the demon have been shown at least having a toast to his fallen frenemy in the bar later?  Either that or another angel stepped in as a substitute, since these stunt demons and angels are interchangeable. 

 

“All in the Family” 

Rest in Peace Kevin Tran.  Your trip up to Heaven was long overdue.  Thank God that God was in the building to give us that very hasty but satisfying resolution. 

Okay, yeah, God would have been the obvious choice here as well, but here me out.  Were you really happy with that resolution?  They brought Chuck back for THAT?  He didn’t get a chance to tell Castiel thanks for all his devotion and service, he didn’t get to energize Heaven and give the angels new hope, and he didn’t even get to have a small chat with his very faithful and loyal servant, Sam Winchester!  No, instead he complained about him to Metatron.  He was just there and everyone was cool with it like he was a messy houseguest.  All Dean had to do was talk Amara down from her temper tantrum?  I rest my case.  Kevin got the better end of the deal. 

 

The awards continue on Page 4...