Home Articles Season Four Recap - "Lucifer Rising"

Recap - "Lucifer Rising"

Here we go, the last recap of season four! I hope the ten of you that read these things enjoy this one, for its one of my longest yet. Too many scenes triggered the thought process!

I tingle with anticipation the second “The Road So Far” comes up, because I know what’s coming. The season summary to the traditional season finale theme song, “Carry On Wayward Son.” So, is it awesome compared to the other seasons? Hell yeah, maybe even more so, since this season was so good. I’m calling season four the series best. There, I said it. I especially got all stoked at the “Don’t you cry no more,” as Sam walks out on Dean from the previous episode. Awesome.

It’s the St. Mary’s Convent Ilchester, Maryland in 1972. There’s a chapel, and you know since this is Kripke’s episode that some very wicked crap is about to go down. In this case, a priest at the alter gets a pretty big stream of black smoke crammed down his throat. Must be a high on the food chain demon. This priest now comes with cavalier attitude when lecturing nuns, who are scared over his behavior, but not scared enough to run for their lives. Silly nuns.

We pretty much know it’s Azazel before even seeing the yellow eyes just by the way he talks. After blah, blah, blahing his way through The Lords Prayer, he mentions how he feels like he’s been wandering the desert for years. Considering in the Book of Enoch, Azazel was bound and cast into the desert as punishment, that’s pretty much correct. He locks the door and mentions he’s been looking for his father, whose in jail because their dad put him there. Ah, get it, he’s looking for Lucifer.



He goes on to reveal that the very convent they’re in is the place where his father’s cage door is. “Life is funny.” A nun tries to interrupt and gets a “Shut your freaking pie hole you little slut!” Okay nuns, this is the point where you guys are supposed to start running because something isn’t right. The priest smiles and goes on over the irony of the place. The location does kind of make sense, since his dad used to be an angel. He theorizes that some dumb bastard got a jolt of “holy juice” and decided to build a “nun factory.” “Right idea, wrong angel.” His eyes go yellow, he pulls out a knife, and says “So um, if any of you gals are the praying type, now would be good time to start.” Then behind the closed (and locked) doors we hear nuns screaming while the camera moves in on a heavenly angel statue. Nothing is sacred with Kripke, is it?

Bird of the apocalypse and yes, they’re for real this time.

A slow focus on a very pensive (and somber) Sam. There’s an abandoned house, and Ruby’s yellow classic mustang. Other than the fact it’s a 69 Mach, I’ve never been impressed with Ruby’s car. Maybe because I’m more partial to the 1965 convertible models. Plus I hate that color. Sam is lost in his own depressive funk, and Ruby tries to play friend, but sucks at it. Sam is ready to go, but Ruby presses further. She tells him Dean was wrong for what he said to him but Sam says he was right. “I don’t blame him after what I did.”



Ruby tries to give him the consolation, they’ll patch things up after. “You’re talking like I’ve got an after,” Sam replies. “I can feel it inside me Ruby. I’ve changed, for good. There’s no going back now.” Ruby tries again, but Sam insists on staying in self-loathing mode. “Look, I know what I gotta do. It’s okay, I’m just saying, Dean’s better off as far away from me as possible.” Sam’s ready to get this done with and they get a move on. Enough with the pity party Sam! Call your brother.

Now, it’s time for the same slow focus onto Dean’s pensive face. Oh you two, you’re killing me with this family strife! Bobby calls out to Dean, and instantly Dean has the better end of the deal. I’ll take Bobby over Ruby any day! Dean is in Bobby’s library, looking out the window. Bobby asks if he’s heard a word he’s said. Dean refuses to call Sam. “Don’t make me get my gun boy,” Bobby tells him. Mental note, don’t get on the wrong side of Bobby. Dean defends they are too close to Armageddon and they’ve got “bigger fish to fry.” Bobby tries to talk sense into him, trying to remind Dean that no matter what Sam’s done he’s his brother and he’s drowning, but Dean has a pity party of his own. “It’s too late.”



Bobby tells him to try again, but Dean is being a whiny brat. “I’ve gotta face the facts. Sam never wanted part of this family. He hated this life, ran away to Stanford first chance he got. Now it’s like déjà vu all over again. Well I’m sick and tired of chasing him. Screw him, he can do what he wants. Sam’s gone, he’s gone. I’m not sure if he’s still my brother anymore. If he ever was.”

Bobby, not being the fan of whining, turns around, throws everything off his desk in one clean swipe and let’s Dean have it. “You stupid, stupid, son of a bitch! Well boo hoo, I am so sorry your feelings are hurt, PRINCESS. Are you under the impression that family’s suppose to make you feel good? Make you an apple pie maybe? They’re supposed to make you miserable! That’s why they’re family!” Bobby, this is the most awesome you’ve been in a LONG line of awesome. I bow right now to your greatness. Another thing I bow too? Kripke for not killing Bobby. We get him in season five! I’m so relieved that I don’t mind that this is his only scene in the episode.



Dean brings up how he told Sam not to walk out the door and he did anyway, and Bobby not only points out that Dean sounds like a whiny brat (see!), he sounds like John. He calls John a coward. Dean takes offense, but Bobby has a great point. “He’d rather push Sam away rather than reach out to him. That don’t strike me as brave. You are a better man that your daddy ever was. So you do both of us a favor, and don’t be him.”

Dean swallows his pride and says nothing, turning back to the window to think it through. He turns around when he realizes Bobby is right, but suddenly he’s not in South Dakota anymore. He’s in Jupiter and the Infinite Beyond from 2001: A Space Odyssey. Kripke you twisted bastard. Castiel greets him with that trademark, "Hello Dean," and tells him it's almost time, like the world's gonna end or something. Oh wait, it is.




Last Updated (Wednesday, 23 June 2010 22:07)

 
Comments (15)
1 Saturday, 23 May 2009 14:00
Elle
I love your recaps, Alice. The commentary you add cracks me up and you also notice many details that I missed during the first (and thus far only) viewing of this episode.

Zachariah was one of my favourite characters and since he wasn't killed, I really hope to see him again. He was evil but in that self-righteous, puritantical way that's even more disturbing than just regular evil. I loved the snarky exchanges with him and Dean. Zack was a great verbal-sparring partner.

Ruby, Ruby, Ruby. Now, knowing her diabolical endgame, I have to go back and re-watch all the episodes involving her. The fact that Lillith was in on the plan allows many other things to click - like, for example, why Lilith was able to allegedly boot Ruby out of her blonde-body in NRFTW but then Ruby was able to climb her way out of Hell again so quickly. The other thing that comes together is why Azazel opened the door to Hell - because they needed to get Lilith out. I love the common, yet subtle threads that run through and connect just about every episode. Everything on SPN has such a great pay off.

I'm eager to see where Cas will be taken next season. So much potential.

Thanks again for the recap and accompanying pictures, Alice! I think that first picture with YED is one of the creepiest shots, ever.
Owner's reply:
Saturday, 23 May 2009 20:09
alice
Thanks elle! You know Kripke gave me a lot to work with as far as screencaps. There were several other parts I so wanted one, but couldn't get a good snapshot because the screen was too shaky. I guess that's what happens with a show that thrives on action.

That's why I love doing these recaps, for I end up catching so much myself when writing them. This one was especially a treat.
2 Saturday, 23 May 2009 15:42
Suze
Actually, now you mention it, the hot-monkey-demon-sex was one of my favorite bits ... Laughing

This was such an enjoyable episode it's really hard to pick out high points but 'ere goes anyway ...

Bobby's rant. What a guy ... sigh.
Ruby revealed and promptly skewered. Hurrah.
Cas crosses the Rubicon. Yay!
Chuck and his laydeez. Bless ... please don't die.
Sam sees the light. His face when he listened to the doctored voicemail nearly finished me off permenantly.
Dean being Dean. Dude.
Mutual clutching at the end. The boys are back. JOY.

So it's all good and roll on September, and Alice, you're just being paranoid, I'm sure there's at least 15 of us hanging on your every word ...
Laughing
Owner's reply:
Saturday, 23 May 2009 20:15
alice
15 of you? Aren't you being kind. Smile Actually, the hubby and I were going through the site stats this morning and it's amazing how few hits these recaps get compared to the other stuff. That could be a bummer, since it takes days for me to put them together with the level of detail I do. I suppose I keep doing them though, for the ten of you and myself, for I learn something. In the end, isn't that all that matters?

I couldn't agree more with your high points. I didn't hate the monkey sex either, but considering they were torturing the poor woman in that same room, it seemed weird.
3 Saturday, 23 May 2009 15:43
elle2
Awesome, just awesome!

This season was fabulous from start to end and gave so much character growth and exposition and a very satisfying end to Ruby...her story is awesome! Still, I'm totally glad she's gone!

I loved the whole point you made about Dean so isolated in the big golden gilded room...that is an excellent shot. Like you I thought Dean knocking the angel to the ground and smashing it and then looking guilty when Cas caught him was too funny. Also, love the foreshadowing there...an angel 'falls' to the floor and Cas appears -- knew you had it in you Cas.

You reviews and recaps are great for I get to go back and pick up little bits that I missed the first time around.

I'll be honest, I'm glad hellatus is here, time to process all the greatness of this season and the series as a whole. Processing...processing...processing
Owner's reply:
Saturday, 23 May 2009 20:16
alice
You're telling me! Processing, processing, processing... My head is about ready to explode!
4 Saturday, 23 May 2009 17:43
random
its Carry on Wayward son. Its a misconception that it is Carry on my wayward son because of the lyrics but I own the album and its Carry on Wayward son. Just thought you should know otherwise great article.
Owner's reply:
Saturday, 23 May 2009 20:18
alice
D'oh! Embarrassed

Actually, I'm VERY grateful you pointed that out. My brother-in-law is a huge Kansas fan, and if he saw me make such an error (for yes, I know better), well, let's just say the family get togethers become unpleasant. He's that particular! Laughing

Error fixed, and thanks for checking the rest of it out.
5 Saturday, 23 May 2009 22:18
Julie
"Awesome" review Alice! Love your recaps and all the other interesting items. Your sense of 'fandom' is exactly what many of us want.

Who cares if we are a select few?? Smile

I look forward to many more articles that keep us busy over hellatus.

ps it's 'fait accompli' Wink
Owner's reply:
Sunday, 24 May 2009 12:08
alice
Thanks Julie! I changed the fait accompli. When I type these up, I usually put something down as a placemarker along with a little note to check the accuracy on the internet before posting. I had that on the list, but missed it. I'm so lucky you guys are around to cover me!

Nah, I don't care if it's a select few either. That was my cheekiness coming through when I saw how few hits these recaps get compared to everything else. There's a core bunch that loves them, and that's good enough for me! I like doing them too much.
6 Saturday, 23 May 2009 23:06
trina
I LOVE the theory that Ruby was in cahoots with the angels. In some ways it's the only thing that makes sense. Yikes, Sam never really had a chance. One issue I have with this season though is why were the angels so against Sam using his powers? The head angels knew that killing Lilith was the final seal, and that Sam was the only one who could do it. So...why instruct the "grunts" on the ground to stop him?

Also, this season has been incredibly polarizing within the more hardcore (some would say obsessed and overinvested) fans of the show. For some it has become a blame game. My opinion is that the true blame lies with Castiel. He is the only "good" character that had all of the information and chose to do nothing until it was too late. In fact, he was actively working towards the apocolypse until the very end.
Owner's reply:
Sunday, 24 May 2009 12:24
alice
You are so right, Sam never did have a chance. Technically, he was doomed before he was even born. It's really sad actually.

I agree with Elle about Castiel. I keep thinking of what he told Dean in "On The Head Of A Pin", which is "They don't tell me much." I think he was kept in the dark until the very end, when the Zachariah was sure he had his loyalty. Castiel does shoulder some of the blame for not acting fast enough, but considering angels by nature are supposed to be obedient, that was an impossible and centuries long mindset to overcome. It's incredible how much Dean has affected him. I can't wait to see what happens to our on the lamb angel next season.

You are also so right about this season being polarizing. I feel lucky that everyone here is a level headed bunch! Thanks for your interesting points.
7 Sunday, 24 May 2009 00:26
Elle
Trina, you raise a good point with regard to the "grunts" and the threats to stop Sam if Dean didn't. Hmm. The only explanation I can think of is that it was meant to keep of appearances on the part of Heaven. They needed to appear opposed so that, outside the upper echelon, nobody caught on to their ultimate endgame. Interesting to ponder though, isn't it?

I don't think that Ruby was working with the angels, as she stated only Lilith knew about her double-agent status, but I wonder if the angels didn't deduce that she was evil based on the fact that (1) she's a demon, (2) she wanted Sam to kill Lilith too (3) she's a demon. I guess at this point it's a little up in the air as to who actually twisted the voicemail. I tend to think angels because I don't know that Ruby would have the power to manipulate it. Maybe her smirk had more to do with reading Sam as he listened to the vm and knowing it was the final push based on his reaction. Hmmm. Now I really want to know. Maybe a deleted scene with satisfy the mystery.

With regard to Castiel, I respectfully disagree with blaming him. Recall, that he only had very few of the facts and when he did learn that Heaven was trying to bring about the apocalypse, he attempted to warn Dean and was ripped back 'upstairs' for some reindoctrination. In the last two episodes, following his stint in Heaven, I think that his action stems from a few things:

1) That he was actually reprogrammed, for lack of a better word, with the "God's will" thing - we've seen that Cas has serious issues with questioning his Father. Thinking back over the season, it was only as Cas grew closer to Dean (and by extension, to understand humans better) that you begin to see his discomfort with his orders. It takes him a long, long time to even vocalize his doubt (and this, similar to the motivation in his decision to defy Heaven in LR, is the result of witnessing Dean’s complete and utter desolation and torment upon learning he broke the first seal – Cas takes many cues from Dean and/or the going-ons around Dean). Suddenly, it’s not as black and white anymore because he’s beginning to experience just what this humanity thing is all about. Emotions, sacrifice, suffering, family, friends – he doesn’t have grasp of this at first. Think about how stoic he was in the first appearance versus the last few. It was very apparent that Cas had become Castiel again after he was pulled back to Heaven in “The Rapture” – more closed off and inhuman again, superior even.

2)He really wanted to believe that this was the best way to bring about peace for all involved, especially Dean. As his humanity barometer, Dean is Castiel's measure of the world and he witnessed the pain and suffering Dean was undergoing and couldn’t understand what was so wonderful about the status quo if people like Dean were made to suffer for always. Cas explained to Dean that he would have peace after all was said and done. Deep down, I don't think he believed it which was why he finally broke down and helped the boys even at the risk of his own existence.

So I don't think he was actively working towards the apocalypse until the very end because he wasn't aware that was where his orders were leading. Really, the only thing he did was release Sam. Yes, he did get the pledge from Dean to follow the orders of Heaven, but it seemed that he struggled with that too. He was quietly assessing and evaluating things in his own silent Castiel way for the majority of LR. The fact that he felt the need to defend his position and explain himself to Dean says to me that he was still trying to convince himself that he was doing the right thing. Very similar to Sam struggling to come to terms with the idea that he has to kill and drink this nurse, who aside from the demon guest inside is still an innocent human being. Means to an end. Cas couldn’t justify it, ultimately, because he was too close to Dean.

Poor Cas falls under the same heading as Sam and Dean – pawn.
8 Sunday, 24 May 2009 12:12
Bevie
Alice - I have to say I love love LOVE your recaps, even though I never (I think) ever commented on them.

There are so many great comments and analyses by others that I don't feel I would be contributing. I always feel that to just say I love them isn't enough. Not very interesting post. LOL

Anyway, please don't feel you do all that work for 10 readers. I'm sure there are many like me who enjoy but don't comment. I love the screencaps and the emotional way you do the recap and that there is no nastiness to spoil it for me. Also, I miss a lot of the dialogue and get it through your article.

I guess from now on I'll comment even though it is only to say "I love your recap".

I enjoy all of your articles. I only come to the friendly blogs now, and they include yours, Bardicvoice, Tina Charles and Gaelicspirit. Can't stand the stupid rivalries going on at others.

I love Supernatural, the boys (Dean I adore) and hope it goes on for a few more years with Kripke aboard.

Thanks Alice for all that you do for us.
Owner's reply:
Sunday, 24 May 2009 12:36
alice
Thank you so much Bevie, but there's no need to feel obligated to comment. My expectation is to speak only when you have something to say. Reading is good too! I usually get the stats to see how many are actually reading, and even though it's low, it's enough where I'll always do these. I learn so much by going through this exercise. Plus, I feel obligated to share this knowledge, whether it be ten people or ten thousand.

I'm so thrilled you find this blog to be a friendly site. There are so few anymore, and I so agree about Bardicvoice. I read her stuff too with delight, although I usually don't comment there because very few know that fluffykitty2001 is me. I'm very anonymous at LJ. It's so good to know how many people enjoy her work.

I'm going to be doing recaps soon for some of my favorite season one and two episodes (plus do the ONE season three one I'm missing), so as long as you keep reading, I'm happy. Thanks for sharing your thoughts!
9 Sunday, 24 May 2009 12:16
Jodie
I totally agree with Elle, i dont think Cas is to blame at all.
I think Cas cared about Dean because he wanted Dean to be in peace after he had seen all of Deans pain over Sam.

Anyways, the recap was brilliant like always. I didnt get into Supernatural till the start of this season so i ended up going back and watching it through the internet. while i was looking for it i found this website and read all your recaps while i went along and it made me see all the different things that i had missed. I love your recaps there fab Very Happy

I love that Ruby is dead Finally!
Castial has finally come to his senses and seen th bad ways of the angels (hahaa, weird much).

Cant wait for the next season! I'm sure its gonna be explosive Very Happy
Owner's reply:
Sunday, 24 May 2009 12:45
alice
Thanks Jodie! You know, you're a testament to how stupid networks like The CW have it so wrong. So many people I know, and on this site, have discovered Supernatural in either the third or fourth season. Lord knows I'm getting the ladies at Taekwondo hooked right now. They only agreed to check it out once I mentioned the two really hot leads (plus the third isn't darned shabby either). We're some pretty hormonally charged ladies!

Anyway, silly networks have this mentality that by the third season, loyal viewers have stabilzed and its impossible for a show to grow viewers at that point. Considering two of the shows with the largest ratings increases this year (when 99% of the shows had declines) were "How I Met Your Mother" and "Supernatural", that goes to show you how wrong they are.

Also, thanks about the recaps. I'm going to do my best to get more in for season one and two, so those like yourself can benefit from those. I'm so glad you found this site.

Exactly right. Next season will be intense!
10 Sunday, 24 May 2009 14:00
Clarice
Oh I can't believe your recaps are this under appreciated! Well, I think they're great, please keep writing!
11 Monday, 25 May 2009 03:42
Bethany
Elle, it had never occured to me that to free Lillith was the reason for opening the Devil's Gate - good point! YED plan was more involved than I thought!

I don't think that Ruby and the Angels were working together rather that Zach and the higher angels knew what she was doing and made no effort to hinder her activities. I also think that Cas and the other grunts on the ground didn't know what was going on or Sam's role and they were just saying what they thought,ie Demons powers are bad, they have something to do with YED he should stop using them. It's like a big company where the senior management don't tell the workers what's going on so they decide to make decisions based on the intel they have which they think is for the best not realising that it actually goes against senior managements master plan. Methinks the angels need to work on their communication and me on my grammar that was a long sentence!

But pretty much awesome, my heart nearly broke at Sam's face hearing the faux VM. The episode started out slow but it just sped up so that by the end it was just hitting us over the head with one revelation after another. My mind is still racing about it and I first saw the episode, what was it two weeks ago it aired?

Final point I promise - It's one of the things that I love most about this show that you do get the action and the drama and the angst but it still manages to retain it's sense of humour. Dean's face when Cas caught him breaking the statue, Cas saying "we're making it up as we go along" (welcome to team winchester Cas - we have cookies!) and the moment where Chuck puts his hand on Cas' shoulder in a moment of soildarity and Cas gives him the 'no touching' look. Priceless! High drama, yet you can't help but laugh but it still never detracts from the gravitas of the moment, it doesn't pull you away from the situation or danger they're in, rather it adds to it. That is a difficult line to walk and yet this show manages to pull it off time and time again. Only one other filmmaker/showrunner (whatever you call them) has managed to pull that off - humour within the drama that doesn't take you from the moment and that's Joss Whedon. I may anger some Whedonites but I think Kripke is easily in the same league.

Oh and Dean likes redheads? Yay! I'm also in!
12 Monday, 25 May 2009 04:13
Narcissus
Alice, you officially have a new fan Very Happy

Oh and I just have to say, the part when Sam was listening to "Dean's" voicemail, I ended up on the floor, somehow both choking and screaming. That was way too painful to watch. DAMN YOU KRIPKE!!
13 Monday, 25 May 2009 17:01
alysha
I tend to lurk here more than post....sorry! But I bet you have far more than ten readers!

I enjoyed replaying the finale again in my mind as I read the recap. Kripke did well on this!! And he let Bobby live, which means a lot to me.

As many before me posted there was a two year plan to get Sam to fold. Bet the powers that be (and I bet Ruby was in cahoots with Zach) never imagined it'd take two years to break Sam. It only worked with him separated from Dean.

Now the brothers need to realize that only together can they save the world.
14 Tuesday, 26 May 2009 04:15
Suze
Bethany, I'm a Jossgurl from way back and I think you're quite right about he and Mr. K being cut from the same cloth. The combination of black humour and little shafts of sweetness they sprinkle on the action is very similar, and ( dirty secret alert ... ) at the moment I'm far more smitten with Supernatural than I am with Dollhouse!

With regard to the whole who knew what and when thing, my feeling is that the Higher Powers ( Zach et al ) knew that the best way to manipulate Dean was to threaten Sam so they let the footsoldiers ( Cas, Uriel etc ) think he was the enemy. I don't think Cas knew about the grand design at first and when he found out ( via Anna? ) He rushed off to tell Dean and was nobbled and brainwashed back to the party line which only lasted until he got a facefull of stroppy humanity from our boy and promptly had a relapse.

I think there could be some kind of a free will verses blind obedience plot strand going on here ... Zach said that God has left the building but I'm thinking more along the lines of he's hiding behind a curtain to see how things pan out when his minions think they're unobserved ...

I think it was Zach who doctored the message on Sam's phone, Dean's mobile didn't work unless he ( Zach ) wanted it to so he let the call go through because when he'd finished twisting it he knew it would push Sam over the edge ... Nasty bastard that he is ( Zach, that is not Sam, obviously ... Sam's a poor hard done by sweetheart and needs a cuddle )
15 Tuesday, 26 May 2009 10:48
vana naine
probably some people read your reviews first from Blogcritics and does not bother to click here too?
I did so for some time, until I understood that often the recaps are more detailed here, and well, pictures does not hurt either.

Add your comment

Very HappySmileWinkSadSurprisedShockedConfusedCoolLaughingMadRazzEmbarrassedCrying or Very SadEvil or Very MadTwisted EvilRolling EyesExclamationQuestionIdeaArrowNeutralMr. GreenGeekUber Geek
Your name:
Comment:
  The word for verification. Lowercase letters only with no spaces.
Word verification: