Supernatural Guests Bonus Round
Part 5
Hello all! Many moons ago, I began a little project here at the WFB, and while life required a mini-sabbatical from writing - I have returned and am determined to complete this. So, it’s been a long, long time coming, but it’s finally here! Part 5. I have a few more lists after this (yes, there has been a lot of guests!) and my goal is to complete all the guest stars through end of season five – then begin anew for Summer Hellatus 2011! With any luck, I’ll have the next instalment out next week. Anyways, enjoy! Apologies if there are any repeats, I’ve tried to ensure there aren’t but inevitably one will sneak through here or there.
**
Molly McNamara

Played by Tricia Helfer
First Appearance: Road Kill
Last seen: heading in to the bright, white Hereafter
Mr. Wyatt

Played by Chad Willet
First and only appearance: After School Special
Last seen: positing a question of happiness to a struggling Sam.
Jeb Dexter

Played by Luke Camilleri
First and only appearance: Criss Angel is a Douchebag
Last seen: dying
Candace Armstrong

Played by Barbara Kottmeier
First and only appearance: Wishful Thinking
Last seen: explaining her status as a “natural sensitive” with a ghostly peeper
Charlie The Magician


Played by John Rubinstein and Michael Weston
First and only appearance: Criss Angel is a Douchebag
Last seen: in a fatal final performance
Rich

Played by Brian Skala
First and only appearance: Hookman
Last seen: wishing he’d just stayed home that night.
Joseph Welch

Played by Steve Railsback
First and only appearance: Pilot
Last seen: getting a well-earned verbal lashing from one Samuel Winchester
Sheriff Jodie Mills

Played by Kim Rhodes
First appearance: Dead Men Don’t Wear Plaid
Latest Appearance: Weekend at Bobby’s
Last seen: helping Bobby around the law
Cindy McClellan

Played by Juliana Wimbles
First and Last Appearances: When the Levee Breaks; Lucifer Rising
Last seen: sharing a drink with Sam and Ruby
Claire Becker

Played by Shannon Powell
Fist and last Appearance: The Usual Suspects
Last seen: as one scary-looking, justice-seeking death-omen
Julia Wright

Played by Ever Carradine
First and only appearance: I Believe the Children Are Our Future
Last seen: being dispossessed (again)
Kali

Played by Rekha Sharma
First and last appearance: Hammer of the Gods
Last seen: saved heroically by Gabriel, much to his detriment
Karla

Played by Lara Gilchrist
First and only appearance: Sam, Interrupted
Last seen: underestimating Dean
Sue-Ann Le Grange

Played by Rebecca Jenkins
First and only appearance: Faith
Last seen: getting touchy-feely with a PO’d reaper
Tammi

Played by Marisa Rameriz
First and Only Appearance: Malleus Maleficarum
Last seen: demonstrating the attractive features of Ruby’s knife
Craig Thursten

Played by Shane Meier
First and Only Appearance: Hell House
Last seen: Oddly enough, alive and well in a record shop
Creedy

Played by Jon Van Ness
First and only appearance: Bad Day at Black Rock
Last seen: foiled by...Batman!
Thomas Gregory

Played by David Monahan
First and only appearance: Houses of the Holy
Last seen: ascending
For all the latest Supernatural info and article links, follow The Winchester Family Business on Twitter at @WinFamBusiness
**
Molly McNamara

Played by Tricia Helfer
First Appearance: Road Kill
Last seen: heading in to the bright, white Hereafter
Mr. Wyatt
Played by Chad Willet
First and only appearance: After School Special
Last seen: positing a question of happiness to a struggling Sam.
Jeb Dexter
Played by Luke Camilleri
First and only appearance: Criss Angel is a Douchebag
Last seen: dying
Candace Armstrong

Played by Barbara Kottmeier
First and only appearance: Wishful Thinking
Last seen: explaining her status as a “natural sensitive” with a ghostly peeper
Charlie The Magician


Played by John Rubinstein and Michael Weston
First and only appearance: Criss Angel is a Douchebag
Last seen: in a fatal final performance
Rich

Played by Brian Skala
First and only appearance: Hookman
Last seen: wishing he’d just stayed home that night.
Joseph Welch

Played by Steve Railsback
First and only appearance: Pilot
Last seen: getting a well-earned verbal lashing from one Samuel Winchester
Sheriff Jodie Mills

Played by Kim Rhodes
First appearance: Dead Men Don’t Wear Plaid
Latest Appearance: Weekend at Bobby’s
Last seen: helping Bobby around the law
Cindy McClellan

Played by Juliana Wimbles
First and Last Appearances: When the Levee Breaks; Lucifer Rising
Last seen: sharing a drink with Sam and Ruby
Claire Becker

Played by Shannon Powell
Fist and last Appearance: The Usual Suspects
Last seen: as one scary-looking, justice-seeking death-omen
Julia Wright

Played by Ever Carradine
First and only appearance: I Believe the Children Are Our Future
Last seen: being dispossessed (again)
Kali

Played by Rekha Sharma
First and last appearance: Hammer of the Gods
Last seen: saved heroically by Gabriel, much to his detriment
Karla

Played by Lara Gilchrist
First and only appearance: Sam, Interrupted
Last seen: underestimating Dean
Sue-Ann Le Grange
Played by Rebecca Jenkins
First and only appearance: Faith
Last seen: getting touchy-feely with a PO’d reaper
Tammi

Played by Marisa Rameriz
First and Only Appearance: Malleus Maleficarum
Last seen: demonstrating the attractive features of Ruby’s knife
Craig Thursten

Played by Shane Meier
First and Only Appearance: Hell House
Last seen: Oddly enough, alive and well in a record shop
Creedy

Played by Jon Van Ness
First and only appearance: Bad Day at Black Rock
Last seen: foiled by...Batman!
Thomas Gregory

Played by David Monahan
First and only appearance: Houses of the Holy
Last seen: ascending
| < Prev | Next > |
|---|




Comments
Great to have you back.
It’s amazing just how many guest appearances this show has had.
I remember being surprised that the characters Cindy McClellan (When the Levee Breaks) and Karla (Sam Interrupted) were played by different actresses. They looked so much alike.
RSS feed for comments to this post